SUBSCRIBE NOW

Enjoy all your local news and sports for less than 7¢ per day.

Subscribe Now or Log In

Marble Falls councilor disputes further cost overruns on One Water project

Marble Falls Place 3 Councilor Dave Rhodes leads the discussion on the decision to postpone. Staff photo by Maci Cottingham

Marble Falls City Council has postponed a decision on reallocating $296,720 in engineering funds for the One Water wastewater treatment project, the largest construction project in the city’s history.

During its Nov. 17 meeting, council voted to revisit the proposal Dec. 1, when Plummer Associates representative Robert Adams, who has been involved with the project since its inception, is expected to be present.

The proposed reallocation would shift $296,720 within Plummer’s existing contract budget, moving $252,000 from post-construction services to additional design work and $44,720 to project management and quality control. The post-construction services could require a separate contract amendment before that work begins.

Councilor Dave Rhodes, who served on council when the original agreement was approved and spearheaded the One Water project, questioned the need for the additional allocation.

“This is disappointing. We knew this was complex, and we also knew going into this project that we’re cutting new dirt here, and we’re still cutting new dirt,” Rhodes said in the meeting. “And I think that Plummers’ been more than well compensated and continue to be compensated under the contracts. You’re not getting a yes out of this seat.”

Rhodes said that while the reallocation would not create an additional cost for the city, it would reduce funds available for other project needs.

“We’re spending money. It’s 300,000 bucks that we’re not going to have to spend somewhere else,” Rhodes said.

Perran Hutton with Plummer Associates said the additional allocation accounts for work performed over the past year that was not included in the original scope, including efforts related to securing additional funding through the Texas Water Development Board.

The project was originally estimated to cost $87.84 million, but its contract was restructured in February after costs increased by $34 million, bringing the total project cost to $121.84 million.

“It’s a pretty significant chunk of effort over the last year. I think it’s something like 1,200 hours that we spent working on things that were not originally planned in our schedule work,” Hutton said.

Rhodes acknowledged Plummer’s role in helping secure additional funding through the Texas Water Development Board, but emphasized the firm’s responsibility as a project partner.

“Let’s be reasonable here in that if you plumber hadn’t helped us work on GMP 2 and GMP 3 and GMP 4 to get the Texas Water Development Board to cut that extra money, this project would be dead and you wouldn’t be getting paid for any of it,” Rhodes said. “So either we’re partners here or we’re not.”

Council voted 5-0 to postpone the discussion until Dec. 1, with Mayor Pro Tem Craig Magerkurth abstaining.

Background

The One Water facility, the largest construction project in Marble Falls history, broke ground in May 2025 on city-owned land off Colt Circle Drive, behind Walmart. It will replace the city’s more than 70-year-old wastewater treatment plant, which was damaged in the 2018 flood and has struggled to keep pace with population growth.

One Water will more than double the city’s wastewater treatment capacity to 3 million gallons per day and is designed to eventually allow treated wastewater to be reused for irrigation. Originally expected to begin operating by 2028, the project is now scheduled for final completion in May 2029.

maci@thepicayune.com

DailyTrib.com moderates all comments. Comments with profanity, violent or discriminatory language, defamatory statements, or threats will not be allowed. The opinions and views expressed here are those of the person commenting and do not necessarily reflect the official position of DailyTrib.com or Victory Media Marketing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *